Ridley Scott’s The Last Duel, a marvellous historical costume drama that is all too rare in Hollywood these days, is based on a true story that took place in 14th century France, and for those interested, there’s a book, with the same title, by Eric Jager. The premise is that two men, former friends, fought to the death in a trial by duel when one man was accused of raping the wife of the other. If the husband lost, then it would ‘prove’ that the wife was lying, and she would subsequently be burned alive at the stake. If the husband won, well that would prove the wife told the truth. Women were property, so the rape of a woman was a crime against her husband, damn it.
The film opens with the famous duel about to take place and then the film segues into past events and exactly what led these two men, Jean de Carrouges (Matt Damon) and Jacques le Gris (Adam Driver) to this moment in time. The film is divided into three sections with the story told by its three main characters: Carrouges, le Gris and Marguerite de Carrouges. There’s some repetition–not much though thanks to some scene variation, and while you’d expect three wildly differing versions: he said/he said/ and she said, events are startlingly similar.
The film depicts the men starting as comrades in arms, friends, but then division gradually erodes the relationship. Carrouges, a vassal of Comte Pierre d’ Alençon (Ben Affleck) is a great warrior but his impetuosity gets him into trouble while fighting at Limoges. Alençon dislikes Carrouges–not just for his disobedience but also because he considers him to be a clod: dull and boring. At the same time, witty le Gris begins to find favour with Alençon. Alençon is depicted as decadent, hosting orgies at his castle after his wife, usually pregnant, is safety dismissed to bed. The atmosphere at the castle goes a long way to explaining le Gris’ behaviour and attitude towards Marguerite de Carrouges. The message is that Alençon likes to be entertained: bring on the women and bring on le Gris.

One of le Gris’ jobs is to collect levies for Comte d’ Alençon, and that takes him to Carrouges’s castle for payment and later, significantly, to the home of the Robert de Thibouville, the father of Marguerite.
As Carrouges falls in life, le Gris is continually promoted, and their destinies are irrevocably linked long before Marguerite (Jodie Comer) enters the picture. Carrouges needs money after the expected captaincy of a castle, which has been held by the de Carrouges family for generations, falls … yes, you’ve got it … to le Gris. Marguerite, a tremendously sympathetic character, the daughter of a forgiven traitor, comes with a sizeable dowry, plus she’s beautiful to boot. Their marriage is punctuated by er husband’s absences and vicious little moments with her mother-in-law. Marguerite becomes a playing card in the rivalry of these two men, and after le Gris sees Marguerite, he becomes obsessed with her. He steals to Carrouges’s home when Marguerite is alone and there brutally rapes her, and the cad has the audacity to finish, with a toss of his head, claiming that “we could not help ourselves.” In le Gris’ mind, she wanted it just as much as he did.

This is a true story, one so incredible that a fiction writer would probably shy away from its twists of fate, thinking that so many links would be unbelievable, and yet laid out for the film (and no doubt the book) it’s so easy to see that these two men were on a collision course from which only one would walk away. There’s some bad press out there about bad hair and it’s true that Matt Damon sports a mucky mullet while Ben Affleck has bleached blonde hair, but these little asides evaporate in the story’s power. The film’s splendid cinematography pulled me into the grimy world of 14th century France. Bleak castles, flames on bloody battlefields, wars that decimated families and promoted favourites. Small details underscore the story’s power: such as Marguerite’s little feet chained to the seat from where she watches the duel.

In light of the rape charge, Marguerite is abandoned by her friend, constantly picked at by her vicious mother-in-law, and grilled in the courtroom. Jodie Comer delivers a shimmering yet marvelously subdued performance of a woman who faced death by burning at the stake if her husband lost the duel. My big question: how did le Gris know to go to the Carrouges castle when Marguerite was alone? Was she set-up by her mother-in-law? Did le Gris have spies? Anyway, for historical drama fans, this is one to watch.

You must be logged in to post a comment.